Best Pizza in Tampa

Best Pizza in Tampa: Where to Get the Perfect Slice

When it comes to enjoying the best pizza in Tampa, Midtown Tampa is a must-visit destination. This vibrant district offers a variety of pizza options to satisfy every craving, from classic Italian-style pies to innovative creations. Whether you’re drawn to Colony Grill’s famous thin-crust pizzas, BellaBrava’s New World take on Italian classics, Kale Me Crazy’s unique sourdough pizzas, or the hot bar slices at Whole Foods, there’s a flavor for every kind of pizza enthusiast.

Read on at explore all the standout pizza spots in Midtown Tampa, where exceptional flavors and fresh ingredients come together to deliver the perfect slice.

BellaBrava: New World Trattoria at Midtown Tampa

BellaBrava brings the essence of Italy to Tampa, blending Old World flavors with modern flair. At the heart of their menu are the Woodstone oven pizzas, which feature crispy crusts and fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or something more adventurous, BellaBrava delivers with options that are both comforting and exciting.

Why BellaBrava is a Top Spot for Pizza in Tampa:

• Authentic Tuscan Inspiration: BellaBrava transports diners to Italy with recipes rooted in tradition, all while embracing the casual vibe of a trattoria.
• Versatile Menu: Beyond pizza, you’ll find a range of flatbreads, calzones, seafood, and pasta—perfect for groups with varied tastes.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Bring the kids for a family pizza night or enjoy a romantic dinner with wine and an artisanal pie.
• Fresh Ingredients: Their commitment to quality shines through in every bite, with toppings like fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, and house-made sauces.

The Midtown Tampa location also adds a vibrant energy to the experience, making it a perfect spot for lunch, dinner, or a casual weekend hangout.

 

Colony Grill: Home of the Original Hot Oil Bar Pie

For a truly unique take on the best pizza in Tampa, head to Colony Grill at Midtown Tampa. Known for its one-of-a-kind thin-crust “bar pies,” this spot delivers a pizza experience unlike any other. The star of the show? Their signature “hot oil” topping—a spicy, flavor-packed drizzle that takes their pies to the next level.

Originally established in 1935 in Stamford, Connecticut, Colony Grill has perfected its craft over the decades. The bar pie’s compact size, crispy crust, and perfectly balanced toppings make it easy to enjoy, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a slice to-go. While their menu may be simple, the flavors are anything but, focusing solely on pizza to ensure every bite is unforgettable.

Why Colony Grill is a Must-Visit for Pizza Lovers:

• Signature Hot Oil: The pepper-infused hot oil topping adds just the right kick to any pie.
• Crispy Thin Crust: Their iconic “bar pies” feature a crust that’s crisp and light, perfect for pairing with a cold drink.
• Decades of Heritage: Colony Grill’s storied history is reflected in every pie, blending tradition with exceptional flavor.
• Variety in Simplicity: From classic cheese to breakfast pizza topped with egg and bacon, there’s something for everyone.

Midtown Tampa’s Colony Grill combines community-focused hospitality with some of the best pizza in Tampa. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a first-time visitor, their hot oil bar pies are not to be missed!

 

True Food Kitchen: Sourdough Pizza

For the best pizza in Tampa, True Food Kitchen serves up artisanal sourdough creations that combine bold flavors with clean ingredients. From the vibrant Roasted Butternut Squash Pizza to the indulgent Bougie Blanco with black truffle and hot honey, every bite is crafted with care and intention. True Food’s commitment to fresh, organic, and locally sourced ingredients ensures that every pizza is as nutritious as it is delicious.

Pizza Menu Highlights:

• Pepperoni Pizza: Niman Ranch uncured pepperoni, DiNapoli tomato sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
• Grass-Fed Bison Sausage Pizza: Regenerative bison sausage, charred scallion salsa, and fried egg.
• Bougie Blanco Pizza: Parmesan cream, black truffle, organic arugula, and house-made hot honey.
• Margherita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, organic DiNapoli tomato sauce, and basil.

Enjoy a slice of seasonal goodness that’s good for your taste buds, your health, and the planet.

Whole Foods Market: Freshly Baked Pizza

For the best pizza in Tampa, Whole Foods Market delivers fresh, handcrafted pies baked to perfection. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or taking home a whole pizza, you’ll find flavorful options made with premium ingredients, including organic produce and responsibly sourced toppings.

Pizza Menu Highlights:

• Classic Cheese Pizza: A timeless favorite with rich mozzarella and savory tomato sauce.
• Pepperoni Pizza: Topped with high-quality pepperoni for a bold, satisfying bite.
• Veggie Lovers Pizza: Loaded with fresh, seasonal vegetables for a wholesome twist.
• Specialty Pizzas: Rotating creations featuring unique flavor combinations and local ingredients.

Pair your pizza with a crisp salad or your favorite beverage for a complete meal that’s as convenient as it is delicious.

 

More of Standout Spots for Pizza in Tampa

While Midtown Tampa is a standout destination, Tampa’s pizza scene offers plenty of variety for food lovers. Here are some other top places to indulge in the best pizza in Tampa:

1. Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza: If you’re in the mood for New York-style pizza, Eddie & Sam’s is a must-visit. Known for their massive slices and authentic flavors, they use water imported from New York to achieve that signature crust. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or dining in, their menu includes classic options like pepperoni and unique creations such as the buffalo chicken pizza.
2. Due Amici Pizza: Located in the heart of downtown Tampa, Due Amici specializes in both traditional and gourmet pizzas. Their wood-fired oven delivers a perfectly charred crust, and their creative toppings, like truffle oil and arugula, elevate the dining experience. Pair your pizza with one of their house-made cocktails for a night to remember.
3. Forbici Modern Italian: Located in Hyde Park Village, Forbici offers Roman-style pizza with a light, airy crust that’s both crispy and chewy. Their toppings include fresh burrata, prosciutto, and seasonal vegetables, ensuring each pizza is a work of art. The chic atmosphere makes it a favorite for date nights and special occasions.
4. Lee’s Grocery: For a more laid-back experience, head to Lee’s Grocery, a neighborhood gem in Tampa Heights. This cozy spot serves craft beer alongside their thin-crust pizzas, which are made fresh to order. Popular choices include the BBQ chicken pizza and the veggie-packed Garden Delight.

 

What Makes Midtown Tampa a Pizza Lover’s Paradise?

Midtown Tampa is a vibrant hub where food, shopping, and entertainment converge to create the ultimate destination for locals and visitors alike. With options like artisan sourdough pizzas at True Food Kitchen and freshly baked pies from Whole Foods Market, this district is a haven for those seeking the best pizza in Tampa. From classic flavors to creative toppings, every pizza spot in Midtown delivers quality and variety.

But Midtown Tampa offers more than just great dining—it’s an experience. After savoring your favorite slice, explore upscale shopping, unwind with a craft cocktail, or stroll through its thoughtfully designed spaces. Events like live music, pop-up markets, and seasonal festivities add an extra layer of excitement, making every visit unique.

Whether you’re planning a casual meal with friends, a family outing, or a post-work hangout, Midtown’s dynamic atmosphere caters to every mood. Pizza may be the highlight, but the district’s mix of exceptional food, stylish boutiques, and lively entertainment makes it a unique Tampa shopping mall worth exploring.

 

Planning Your Pizza Crawl in Tampa

To truly enjoy the best pizza in Tampa, why not plan a pizza crawl? Start your journey at Midtown Tampa with BellaBrava, then venture out to other favorites like Colony Grill and True Food Kitchen. With so many styles and flavors to choose from, Tampa is a pizza lover’s dream.

 

Whether you’re a fan of traditional Italian pies, New York-style slices, or creative gourmet creations, Midtown Tampa’s pizza scene has it all. So gather your friends and family, and discover the best pizza in Tampa at Midtown!